Compare / Belfry
NabShift vs. Belfry
Belfry is security-specific, funded, and built to run payroll for the guards it schedules. That last part is the whole question: does your crew need a system built to employ guards, or a coverage layer that works beside whatever already employs them?
What Belfry does well
Belfry is purpose-built for security operations — scheduling, certification tracking, and integrated payroll and timekeeping, aimed at companies that employ their guards as W-2 staff. Per NabShift's own competitive review (August 2026), Belfry has raised over $30M and runs sophisticated content marketing aimed at security company owners. For a company that wants one vendor to run scheduling and payroll together, that combination is a real advantage.
Questions that reveal whether coverage is still manual
- Which Belfry modules are indispensable?
- Has Belfry eliminated manual call-off outreach?
- Is the workforce W-2, contractor, or mixed?
- Can contractors browse eligible nearby opportunities and claim by text?
- How difficult would it be to change only the coverage workflow?
Where NabShift is structurally different
Belfry may remain the appropriate back-office system. NabShift can specialize in the voluntary coverage loop without replacing payroll, billing, or other Belfry functions.
Claim-first, not offer-and-confirm
Belfry's model offers a shift and asks a guard to confirm. NabShift's board is browse-and-claim: eligible guards see every open post and grab the one they want, by map or by text.
Coverage layer, not payroll system
NabShift doesn't run payroll or file taxes — it exports a timesheet to whatever payroll tool a crew already uses. If your crew runs contractors, there's no W-2 payroll engine to work around.
Published, flat pricing
NabShift's tier pricing is public on this site. Belfry's is quote-only — worth asking what 50-100 guards actually costs before comparing further.
When to stay with Belfry
If your crew is W-2 and Belfry is already running payroll, timekeeping, and scheduling together with genuinely low manual follow-up, unwinding that combination for a narrower coverage tool is a real cost. NabShift is worth evaluating specifically for the coverage loop — filling an open post fast — not as a payroll replacement.
How to test NabShift beside Belfry
Pick one crew, event, or contractor roster and run its open-shift coverage through NabShift for a stretch, while Belfry keeps running payroll and everything else unchanged. Compare fill time and manual contacts on that one slice before deciding whether to expand it.
Show us one difficult shift
We'll recreate the workflow in NabShift and show you how it would run. No migration required.
Show us one difficult shift Try the live demoor email hello@nabshift.com directly